Got a Subrogation Demand Letter in Florida? What to Do Next
General information only, not legal advice. Reading this page does not create an attorney-client relationship. Florida Civil Counsel, P.A., 250 N. Orange Ave., Ste. 1220, Orlando, FL 32801.
Short answer: A subrogation demand letter means an insurance company paid for someone else’s loss and now wants you to repay it. Do not ignore it and do not pay or admit fault right away. Check whether you had insurance, ask for proof of the amount paid, gather your evidence, and get advice before responding.
What is a subrogation demand?
Subrogation lets an insurer that paid its own customer’s claim “step into the shoes” of that customer and seek reimbursement from the person it believes caused the loss. After a car accident in Orlando, for example, the other driver’s insurer may pay for their repairs or rental car and then send you a letter demanding that amount.
These letters often come from the insurer’s subrogation unit, an outside law firm, or a collection agency. They may arrive months after the crash.
First steps after you receive the letter
1. Check whether you had insurance on the date of loss
If you had liability coverage, send the letter to your insurer immediately with your policy number. Your insurer may handle the claim. If your insurer denies coverage or you were uninsured, the demand may be your personal responsibility to address.
2. Read the details carefully
- Date and location of the loss
- The name of the insured the company paid
- The amount demanded and how it was calculated
- Any deadline or threat of suit
3. Request documentation in writing
You can ask for proof of payment, repair estimates and invoices, photos, the police report the company relies on, and any deductible amounts included. Keep copies of everything you send and receive.
4. Do not admit fault or make a payment promise by phone
Calls with a subrogation adjuster or collector can be recorded. A casual “I’m sorry” or “I’ll pay something” can complicate your position later.
Common issues in subrogation claims
Fault
The insurer generally must show you were legally responsible. Under Florida’s comparative fault statute, Fla. Stat. 768.81, fault can be apportioned among the people involved.
Amount of damages
Inflated repair figures, unrelated prior damage, excessive rental days, and duplicate charges are worth checking line by line.
Timing
Florida’s limitations statute, Fla. Stat. 95.11, contains different time periods for different types of claims. Which period applies to a subrogation claim depends on how the claim is characterized and when it accrued, so have a lawyer review the dates in your file rather than assuming the claim is too old or still timely.
What happens if you ignore it?
The insurer may file a lawsuit. If you are served and do not respond within the time allowed by the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, the case can proceed by default toward a judgment.
Options for resolving a subrogation demand
- Disputing liability with evidence
- Negotiating the amount
- A written payment arrangement, if you decide to resolve it
- Defending a lawsuit if one is filed
Any agreement should be in writing and should state that payment resolves the claim in full.
Speak with an Orlando subrogation defense lawyer
Florida Civil Counsel, P.A., 250 N. Orange Ave., Ste. 1220, Orlando, represents people and businesses who receive subrogation demands and lawsuits across Florida. Call (407) 426-4444.
Sources
- Fla. Stat. 95.11 (2026) – https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/95.11
- Fla. Stat. 768.81 (2026) – https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/768.81
Statutes and rules are quoted or summarized from the official sources above as of October 2026. Laws change; confirm current text before relying on it.
General information only, not legal advice. Reading this page does not create an attorney-client relationship. Florida Civil Counsel, P.A., 250 N. Orange Ave., Ste. 1220, Orlando, FL 32801.